The Scottish government plans to consult in 2024 on potentially prohibiting the sale of all disposable vaping products. In response, retailer advocacy group Fed sent officials a letter urging more balance between youth access and adult smoking cessation.
This article explores retailers’ concerns with a blanket disposable vape ban, and their calls for a more nuanced approach.
Background on Scotland’s Planned Disposable Vape Ban
In recent statements, Scottish First Minister Humza Yousaf described disposable vapes as “a threat to public health and the environment.” He indicated the government aims to impose a total ban on selling disposable vapor products like Puff Bar and Elf Bar.
To solicit feedback before enacting a ban, officials intend to launch a public consultation in 2024 on disposable vape prohibitions.
In anticipation, leading retailer group Fed sent a letter asking the government to reconsider a complete ban. They argue it could negatively impact efforts to transition smokers to less harmful vaping alternatives.
Why Retailers Oppose a Total Ban on Disposable Vapes
The Fed outlined several concerns with imposing a blanket ban on disposable vape sales in Scotland:
- Illicit trade – Prohibition removes disposables from legitimate retailers, pushing sales underground to unregulated channels. This fosters growth of dangerous black market vaping products.
- Smoking cessation – Disposables help some hardcore smokers switch to vaping. Eliminating these simple-to-use products hurts reducing cigarette use.
- Safety education – Retailers provide guidance on proper use and disposal. A ban eliminates this point of consumer education.
For these reasons, Fed urged a more balanced approach between limiting youth access and retaining disposables as an off-ramp for adult smokers.
Hussan Lal of St Mirren Food Store has seen many customers quit smoking through disposable vapes. Outlawing these devices removes a cessation aid and harm reduction tool.
Vaping Industry Prepares for Likely Restrictions
While opposed to a total ban, vaping companies acknowledge some limitations on disposable vapes appear likely.
One supplier now develops flavors mirroring popular disposable products in expectation of restrictions. Industry groups launched pro-vaping campaigns ahead of policy changes.
However, political momentum favors curbing teen usage of these easy-to-use vapes. Most observers expect significant disposable vape constraints from both Scotland and the wider UK, despite industry protest.
A Plea for Balance Between Youth Access and Adult Cessation
Fed and retailers contend that outright banning disposable vapes is counterproductive to public health aims. A more nuanced approach is needed to both restrict youth access and provide adults an off-ramp from deadly cigarettes.
Rather than simplistic prohibition, retailers advocate for thoughtfully designed regulations that allow disposables to remain available for smoking cessation purposes. Smart policies can achieve a balance between protecting youth and transitioning adult smokers to reduced harm vaping.