NY E-Cigarette Tax Bill: Groups Urge Hochul to Veto
Public health organizations are urging New York Governor Kathy Hochul to veto legislation that restructures excise taxes on electronic cigarettes. Opponents warn that the proposed tax calculation will slash consumer costs and expand youth access across the state.
The Debate Over Retail Versus Wholesale Tax Rates
Passed by both houses of the New York State Legislature, the bill shifts excise tax collection from the point of retail sale to the wholesale level. Democratic State Senator Leroy Comrie, the bill’s sponsor, stated the legislation aims to enforce New York’s 2020 flavored vape ban by tracking distribution channels directly.
“Our bill would make it more difficult for distributors to distribute to minors and that’s what the focus of the bill has always been,” Comrie said, adding that the measure relieves administrative burdens on small businesses.
However, the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids strongly opposes the bill’s arithmetic. Kevin O’Flaherty, the organization’s associate vice president for state and local policy, pointed out that wholesale prices are typically less than half of retail figures.
“They took a 20% retail tax and made it a 20% wholesale tax, which sounds like it’s the same tax,” O’Flaherty said. “So, if you make it 20% retail to 20% wholesale, you’ve effectively cut the tax by more than 50%.”
| Policy Proposal | Tax Level | Rate | Market Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current Law | Retail | 20% | Standard consumer pricing baseline |
| Pending Bill | Wholesale | 20% | Cuts effective tax burden by over 50% |
| Advocate Target | Wholesale | ~48% | Maintains retail price parity |
To preserve price deterrents for youth, O’Flaherty noted that an equivalent wholesale rate must reach approximately 48%. He also cited warnings from the Department of Taxation and Finance indicating the bill’s language lacks adequate tools for effective enforcement.
Convenience Store Operators Defend the Legislation
The New York Association of Convenience Stores pushed back against calls for a veto, arguing the bill directly targets unlicensed operators.
“This legislation would give New York the tools necessary to crack down on the worst offenders – those flooding our communities with illegal, unregulated vaping products through illicit distribution networks,” said association president Alison Ritchie. “The bill does not lower taxes or make nicotine products cheaper; it simply moves tax collection to the appropriate point in the distribution chain.”
While Senator Comrie stated that technical rate adjustments can be worked out with the executive chamber, advocates continue to press Governor Hochul for an outright veto before the measure takes effect.
- Fiji Cabinet Reviews Tobacco Laws to Tackle Vaping & Illicit Trade - November 16, 2026
- NY E-Cigarette Tax Bill: Groups Urge Hochul to Veto - November 16, 2026
- Iowa Publishes Vape Registry Ahead of December Enforcement - November 14, 2026








