NJOY secured a final victory in its long-running patent dispute when the Unified Patent Court (UPC) Court of Appeal in Luxembourg revoked VMR’s patent EP 3 456 214 in its entirety. The court ruled that the patent lacked an inventive step, overturning a previous decision by the European Patent Office (EPO). This ruling concludes a series of revocation actions NJOY filed against Juul Labs and VMR involving nine different vaporizer patents.
Key Takeaways:
- Final Ruling: The UPC Court of Appeal revoked patent EP 3 456 214, ending the litigation.
- Broad Dispute: NJOY originally challenged nine patents; all have now been revoked or invalidated.
- EPO Alignment: Parallel proceedings at the EPO also resulted in the revocation of key Juul patents.
- Legal Teams: McDermott Will & Schulte represented NJOY, while Thum IP and Bardehle Pagenberg defended VMR/Juul.
